澳洲砍树被hornsby council罚款 $1,500

在澳大利亚房产房屋





更新:

刚刚从court回公司,想到应该update一下,顺利解决,council派他们的律师到法庭,说他们cancel了我的PIN,是他们的错误,不应该给我罚款之类的,总共耗时2mins,当然这当中要感谢我同一个小区的committee,有了他的帮助,council派人来我家看了多次,council major也给我打电话过问了此事,所以个人认为澳洲还是一个讲事实讲依据的国家,也谢谢各位帮我出谋划策






邻居有一颗树,因为顶部的树枝已经死掉了,所以树基本上是斜着长的,前不久把斜过我家的部分都剪了,结果被邻居complain到council了,council找人来视察后,今天寄来罚单,说我们修剪没有书面申请,而且修剪超过10%了,可当时我的确给council打过电话,说会修剪a little bit,但结果是剪多了一点,请问现在的情况怎么办?如果只罚个几百也就算了,$1,500的确不是少数目,请万能的朋友们给点建议吧

下面是应council的要求写的砍树理由:

Dear Warick,

I am writing the letter to response the tree prune issue.
I have moved to Thornleigh since the 1st of June and I love the place located in a quiet leafy setting, overlooking a rainforest reserve, as well as the landscaped backyard that is ideal for entertaining. However, the tree in my neighbour’s backyard has had an effect on the quality of my life.
Following are some bullet points that I would like to highlight to prove why I have to cut the tree cut or get it pruned:

1. Falling leaves, sap and bird droppings
The fact is that fallen leaves create a barrier over the lawn. The leaf mat traps moisture, inhibits sunlight and harbors insects and diseases that can kill patches of even the healthiest grass, as well as for bird droppings. Thus the bottom line is that leaves should be removed regularly. However, it is quite challenge for me to do due to my working hours that 7 days/week (full time job on weekdays, part time on weekend).

While leaving the leaves on the lawn all fallen from the trees may seem like a good way to deal with the problem, it isn’t. The longer the leaves lay around and the thicker they accumulate; the greater the damage that could occur to the grass.

In addition, I am also concerned about the amount of bird poop dropping in my yard which may carry disease and make difficult for us to walk through the yard without stepping on it. Especially when my little nephews come to visit me sometimes, he always complains to me about the mess and the sap discourages him from playing in the backyard grass. In addition, the bird droppings sometimes spots the clothes drying in the backyard.

2. Blocking the sunlight to my property
Everyone loves the sunshine especially in the winter here; however the tree overhang over my fence blocks the sunlight after 11am every morning.

3. Potential damage to my property
As you can see from the original photo, the trend of the tree growth leaning into my backyard and the two thirds of total gravity is on my side. Thus we want to prune the branches to make them balance so as to keep safe.

Apart from the proof listed above, we have also taken some actions before we decided to prune the tree.

1. We put a letter for the request to prune in my neighbour’s letter box, but got no feedback.

2. We have also asked my neighbourhood committee member in my area (his name is John) help to have the permission of the owner of the property where the tree is located - And they feedback to us that we can prune the tree which overhang our side of the fence.

3. To make sure I have council approval, I have called the council and told one of the staff my situation and he said I do not need get permission from council only that I should speak with my neighbour.(You can check the record from the council phones)

4. I have also sent the message of apologies to my neighbour when they have the concern that we may cut the tree a little more.

Thank you for your time again and all mentioned above are true. I look forward to your reply and your help will be greatly appreciated.

If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me at XXXXXX
Kind Regards,

红色是被砍部分






评论
剪之前咋不跟邻居先沟通下呢?

评论
不懂帮顶。

评论
帮不上忙。深表同情。

评论
不懂帮顶

评论
帮顶

评论

不懂帮顶

评论
我怎么觉得弄倒了啊,你应该向康嫂complain,让邻居砍树啊。
你连手都不用动啊。

评论
bad luck

评论
不懂帮顶

评论
上法院,拿着修剪之前的照片,因为树是斜着长,快要失去㔻衡了,你不得不修剪的,并且已作了电话沟通,修剪费用还应该和邻居分担.

评论
树枝顶部枯死lz你拍照了没?我看就这项可以争辩下。

评论
安慰

评论
lz上个照片来看看。 到底被你修剪到啥程度。

评论
和邻居关系不好吧

评论
邻居太狠了。。。改天找把锁锁了丫们家大门,然后把锁眼灌上502

评论
恶邻

评论
感觉这是得先跟邻居沟通一下,然后跟council认错,求轻罚,但估计可能性不大。

评论
骂死邻居

评论
要邻居每年出清扫落叶费。同时常向康馊投诉。

评论
我以为超过到自己院子里的部分就可以随便剪

评论
难道这树是受保护树种?

评论
啥邻居都有呀

评论

就是。唉,现在反过来了

评论
别家的树长到自家院子不是可以随便剪吗?

评论

跟邻居说了,可能邻居看我们剪的太多了吧

评论
啥人都有

评论
挺惨的,安慰下

评论
我的经验:阎王好见,小鬼难挡。罚单是不会收回的。到法庭去理论, 有可能会有好结果。
澳洲中文论坛热点
悉尼部份城铁将封闭一年,华人区受影响!只能乘巴士(组图)
据《逐日电讯报》报导,从明年年中开始,因为从Bankstown和Sydenham的城铁将因Metro South West革新名目而
联邦政客们具有多少房产?
据本月早些时分报导,绿党副首领、参议员Mehreen Faruqi已获准在Port Macquarie联系其房产并建造三栋投资联

过户律师,悉尼,买房卖房合同,看合同,conveyancer,律师,房产过户

房产房屋

电路维修和灯泡更换报价?

澳大利亚家里客厅和走廊的灯都不亮。大概有17、18个灯泡,是老式的嵌入式射灯,2米高,4层,一层。换一个新灯泡也不管用,我们认为电路有问题。 找了电工,上门费200,换个灯泡人工费50, ...

房产房屋

关于砍伐树木的问题

澳大利亚我家后院有一棵10多米的树。我最近获得了砍伐树木的许可。我在网上找了一家砍树公司报了个价。当我认为价格合适时,我同意了这个价格。官方价格尚未发送。我问他有没有保险,他 ...

房产房屋

公寓公共空间调查

澳大利亚大家好,我是UTS的学生,正在做居民对高层公寓公共空间的需求和满意度的调查。如果有朋友住在4楼或以上的公寓,他们能占你10-15分钟吗?几分钟宝贵的时间做问卷。参与问卷的朋友 ...

房产房屋

请问房子下面的承重柱选砖还是钢?

澳大利亚如题,加的部分离地2米,现在纠结是用砖柱还是钢柱。请帮忙分析价格和质量。谢谢 评论 我在找结构工程师,我这里说的不算 评论 砖墩之间的最大距离不能超过3米,最小290x290mm一张 ...

房产房屋

小户型(共4套)卖5000万,什么情况

澳大利亚小户型(一共4户)5000万卖,怎么回事,挂卖家名卖了 http://www.domain.com.au/77-81-... nsw-2027-2018476036 评论 Harbour front , 超过1,000平方米的土地,12间卧室,12间浴室和8个停车位,可欣赏歌剧院 ...

房产房屋

新壁炉首次使用

澳大利亚为什么第一次使用新的木柴壁炉要先烧一小柴(量不要太多),然后打开炉门? 点评 大柴不容易一下子点燃,小柴堆起来,很容易从下面生火。开门吸更多氧气。 评论 另外,炉门不是 ...

房产房屋

如果您有定制的中国进口橱柜,请输入

澳大利亚看来市场很不一样。国内流行的奥地利爱格门板在澳洲好像没有。 定制过中国进口橱柜的朋友们,你们是怎么选择橱柜厂的,选择什么样的产品呢? 和中国本土的橱柜厂(也是从中国进 ...

房产房屋

请推荐直饮水机

澳大利亚类似于公司里的水龙头,同时出热水和出冷水。柜子里装了过滤器,不过是家用的。有靠谱的牌子吗?我懒得一直烧热水了。谢谢。 点评 Zip water 点评 Zip,部分型号还可以生产气泡水 ...

房产房屋

Owner builder 家长可以给孩子盖房子吗?

澳大利亚在VIC,女儿房子的父母可以是业主建造者吗?当然,所有权是我的女儿,还不到20岁,我不想自己动手。网上查不到,特地过来问一下,谢谢。 点评 owner builder,顾名思义,就是自己建 ...

房产房屋

HIA 装修合同

澳大利亚O.P. 我们正在审查建筑商提供给我们的 HIA 维多利亚式改建、增建和翻新合同草案,并在下周签署合同之前。 很多事情看起来很简单,但我想知道如果有人可以就以下事项和注意事项提供 ...

房产房屋

租约中断

澳大利亚O.P. 大家好, 由于不幸的情况,我不得不提前解除在 VIC 的租约,需要最少的通知。发出通知时,租约还剩大约 6 个月。 租房期间,我每周支付 500 美元。一旦收到租约中断通知,代理人 ...

房产房屋

现实的体积生成器价格?

澳大利亚O.P. 我听说很多建筑商的底价不包含很多东西,但在墨尔本,您可以实际以 30 平方米左右的 4 床位购买中低档建筑的价格是多少? 例如,Henley 在 2023 年的今天将许多产品的基本价格定在 ...

房产房屋

第 27 条没有给买家?

澳大利亚O.P. 我目前正在出售我的房子,并且已经无条件出售。我的产权转让人已向购买者产权转让人提供第 27 条。 但是,他们无视我的产权转让人的所有联系方式,而且我知道这些信息并未提 ...