新西兰我写给工党的投诉信
在新西兰
刚好在那段时间买了个房，自住的。来了将近15年了，作为被点名的 39.5%的其中一员，不写点啥都对不起自己。不为啥的，就为make点noise..
版主，你要是这都说我有卖广告嫌疑删我贴，我就认定你和工党是以窝的。
Dear Sir/ Madam
My name is Robbi Zeng, I am wring this as formal complaint re couple statements made by Mr T
Twyford on 11/07/2015 in the New Zealand Herald.
According to the statement, Mr Twyford claimed
“...It's staggering evidence that strongly suggests there's a significant offshore Chinese presence
in the Auckland real estate market...”
“...showed for the first time the scale of an issue that was pricing first-home buyers out of the
market...”
(Special investigation: Auckland house prices, New Zealand Herald, 11st July 2015 )
Mr Twyford then further commented on another article saying
“...I'm standing up for Kiwi first-home buyers who currently are denied the dream of affordable
home ownership...” (Labour wanrs against foreign's tsunami, New Zealand Herald,11st July 2015)
I am extremely disappointed by the statements that Mr Twyford made in those occasions because:
1. These two statements from Mr Twyford are implying “Chiese buyers are pushing Kiwi first
home buyers out of the market” which could lead to serious social issues.
2. What Mr Twyford claimed in the statements, are not sensible and some of the people like
myself who has been working hard, contributing to New Zealand are feeling deeply hurt
because we are becoming the attacking point for some Kiwis not able to purchase their first
home.
3. All the statements Mr Twyford made are base on so call “leaked figures” from an
“unidentified firm”. Which means all the “figures” could be invalid at all.
4. It seems Mr Twyford is trying to create more social issue rather than helping Kiwi first home
buyers to get into their home.
I have been in New Zealand for almost 15 years. I grown from a student to a mortgage manager
for one of the main banks in New Zealand. And frankly enough, by leveraging equity in my
investment porfolio I upgraded my family home in the timeframe that Mr Twyford mentioned, and I
am a Chinese too! So count me in for that 39.5% and one of the 4000 houses.
Because of my job, I talk to different people day in day out about mortgage, helping people getting
into their first homes and expending their investment portfolio. In the last a few years, the main
problem I see for many people not able to get into their first home is because they dont have
enough saving. Please note, when I say people, I am talking about Kiwi, Chinese, Indian,
Europeans etc.
I have seen people living on their credit cards, overdrawing their account, and keep applying for
loans. Funny enough, it seems all of their money end up in some similar places: liqor shops, diary,
casino, Lotto tickets, night club, travel etc. Some of these people, still complaining not able to get
into their first home.
I have seen people who has a budget of $450k, trying to purchase their first home in areas such as
Mt Eden, New Lynn, Epsom with big piece of land. We all know expectation like this, simply
unrealistic. And yes, some of these people, still complaining not able to get their first home.
I have also seen people purchaed a small unit in some up and coming areas a few years back as
their first home, they keep working hard, saving hard, repaying their mortgage. And now they own
multiple properties. Again, when I say people here, I mean Kiwis, Indians, Chinese, Europeans,
South Africans etc. I, am one of them.
To cut a long story short, according to my experience of being a mortgage manager and dealing
with home buyers everyday, root problem for people not able to get into their first home is because
their spending habbit: too much lifestyle spending, not enough savings. This happens to people
from all ethincities, not just Kiwis.
And yes, we all know that Asian in general are better savers than Europeans, but this is “gives and
takes”: Europeans enjoy life, work from 9-5, Asian, earn, spend little, save, work from 7-7. In return,
of course Asian are more likely to purchase their homes than Europeans. By keep blaming people
with Chinese surname, is this going to solve the not-saving-enough problem?
To be very honest, the current government has done some very impressive work for introducing
policies such as Kiwisaver first home kick start fund and the soon-to-come 70% LVR rule. This in
my opinion will help first home buyers.
A piece of advice for Mr Twyford and the Labour Party, would it be better to encourage people to
save more and get into their home quicker instead of playing the racist card, and try to set the fire
to some hard working people who have a Chinese surname?
Robbi Zeng
12/07/2015
评论
很奇怪
此新闻一出
很多华人出来跳脚
死命的要摆脱这个所谓的污蔑
我们先不考虑是不是真的9%和40%的关系
就说为什么那么多人要跳脚呢？
清者自清
它说就说了，怕什么呢。
如果它说的不对或者数据组织的不准确，那就是假消息喽，假的真不了，何必这么跳脚呢？
如果是真的。。。嘿嘿，那就小心了，可能如果是真的，也才是为什么这么多人出来跳脚的原因吧？
评论
发信前在检查一下拼写
评论
支持下！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！！
评论
其实真假并不重要，you missed the point
评论
先不管数据的真假，他这篇文章涉嫌煽动人民对立面，容易造成社会的不稳定，这才是为啥这么多人抗议这篇文章。
评论
这个必须得顶.发出声音总比沉默要强.沉默不是金.需要签名的话，加我一个。这些政客没有几个是好东西的,除了胡编乱造来获取政治利益外还能干啥? 有点功夫的话不如好好思考如何振兴经济,增加出口,吸引外资,增加就业等当前最主要问题.2009金融危机房市不好的时候,为啥不唱衰华人购买力不强. 有了问题就要从自身找问题. 房市要动荡的话,新西兰的经济要彻底崩溃的. 工党的这些小丑伎俩是不得华人人心的.下届大选提前说拜拜了.
评论
这些政治老流氓
无非就是既想当婊子又要立牌坊
去年是最好的把资金引入实体经济的一年，它们非要力挺房价，非要靠房地产拉动经济
拉啊，拉啊，现在选民愤怒了，又TM把屎盆子往我们华人头上扣
我们是买了，我们是炒了！谁的错？谁得后背更大的利益？！
基哥我真是服了~
评论
就是，这是真的。煽动民情，这牌打不好会有很严重效果。
要拿选票不一定因为反对而反对。可以多做点好事，树立点正面的形象。。不知道工党怎么想的。
评论
呵呵..
评论
工党现在内讧，每个领导都想尽办法要出风头，可是这个脑袋被门挤的竟然去捅马蜂窝，哈哈
评论
所以中产一定会跳脚维稳啊
我记得我以前就说过：华人中产最怕时局不稳，社会动荡资产价格就会暴跌
我觉得今年真的有戏看了
没想到资本主义国家的政治、经济、文化也是堪比天朝的复杂啊
时局纷纷啊
以后不乱说话了
专心做看客
一出好戏正上演啊~
评论
姓Lee的老外躺槍了、哈哈
评论
试问一下，岛毛的犯罪率远远高于别的族裔，这是地球人都知道的事实吧？为啥主流媒体没有一个敢出来喊的？因为他们知道喊出来的后果是什么。
在连一个租房都不敢拒绝某个族裔，怕惹上“种族歧视”的官司麻烦的国家，在一个对种族关系这么敏感的国度里，他们只敢对华人这样，因为他们知道华人不硬气。
退一步讲，这些数据是事实又怎么样，华人是在没有违法任何法律的情况下买卖房产，有问题吗？你自己没有出台相关的政策来抑制畸形的房市发展，现在反而把屎盆子往华人头上扣，你觉得舒服？
华人就是有你这种想法的人太多了，事不关己，高高挂起，非得要火烧到自己脚边了才知道为时已晚。
评论
本版又有一个处女精华帖，恭喜
评论
华人能不能自己组建个政党阿，统一下华人的实力，把经济上的实力转化到政治上
评论
要统一华人估计难度不小。。。哈哈
评论
是的，就看这里能不能出个牛逼的华人政客
评论
估计national 也可以拿着个做文章,反将labour 一举
评论
支持一个。 有这样的人在工党，工党就难再上台。
评论
這個就算了吧 很多年前就有一個什麼"少數民族黨" 用來對付Winston Peters 之流 當時還不斷在華人電台賣廣告 只記得選舉結果是輸得很慘 甚至連最低要求5%的得票率都沒有 後來選舉過後就自動消失了
聯合新西蘭各少數民族的政黨結果都這樣 還來個只是華人的？ 更不用說 華人本身就是不團結的
海外華人在哪個國家從來都只有當炮灰的命 認了吧 過一會火過了就沒事
评论
支持樓主 不過同意最好做一下proof reading 才寄出去....
评论
两个不同阵营的交战方，为了各自的利益，交上了火。一方狂喊为了新西兰，一方高呼为了中国人，一方引用专业数据，一方注入斗志豪情，一方吃饱了还要嗷嗷乱叫，一方没吃饱必然注定发情。就这么一块蛋糕，苍蝇，老鼠争先恐后，谁炒的越热，谁笑得越欢，谁屁股越净，谁赢得掌声。
评论
汇涓流而成江海，集微声而张大义！
评论
支持。。下次应该叫人check 下语法.
评论
即使这39.5是正确的
他们无法证明多少是移民多少是非移民
他们无法给出以前的华人拥有房产的比率
他们也无法证明那些欧裔的surname买房者里多少是本地人多少是非移民
根本无法进一步分析
评论
楼主似乎忙着打racist牌，可能不太记得论点是什么了。
你这封信，NZ Herald转手直接贴出去放报纸试试，第二天就能看到kiwi示威了吧？
你一再指出kiwi不即省生活习惯不好，把kiwi买不起房问题转成kiwi与本地华人的对立问题，
root problem for people not able to get into their first home is because
their spending habbit: too much lifestyle spending.
And yes, we all know that Asian in general are better savers than Europeans.
楼主到底知不知道矛盾是什么？把海外热钱炒房问题一下子包成本地华人能工作能省钱
你们kiwi要改变生活习惯？如果真要出现民族问题烧房子，楼主这封信绝对少不了功劳吧？
后面还有很多朋友叫好？怕事不够大吗？
评论
Twyford险恶用心很明显！庆幸的是下届选举国家党赢没悬念了！！！！！The Point is here!!
评论
这就是角度和观点的问题。
首先，数据出处不明，
其次，“带有中文姓氏”的买家里，有多少是海外热钱？
第三，在这些问题都没清楚之前打种族牌，是不是不妥？
第四，我已明确提到，总的来说，买不到房的原因，主要是消费习惯引起的。这个问题存在于所有种族。不止kiwi
第五，很概括的说，白人文化比较倾向于享受生活，而亚裔人倾向存钱。这里没有对错，如果乐意享受生活，就别喊买不起房。如果乐意存钱买房，就别喊没有生活。
最后，感谢你评论。乐意看到各方观点。不过很遗憾，因为你觉得这篇文章打的是种族牌来攻击kiwi。这和我初衷完全背道而驰。我自己的工作本身就是帮更多的人买到房。所以不存在任何攻击kiwi的出发点。
共勉
评论
觉得你也是想帮华人的。希望你也写一篇投诉信？