澳洲私校教育是否值得投资,article@SMH

在澳大利亚小学教育




今天SMH的首页money版有篇关于private school的文章,全文连接: http://www.smh.com.au/money/inve ... 20111015-1lq8g.html, 涉及私校优劣,return on investment,如何funding。

摘录一些主要的points

* After all, a year 7 student starting next year will cost $215,000 by year 12 if school fees keep rising at an annual rate of 6 per cent.

* Based on the "ample evidence" that private-school students will earn more "and are more likely to get top jobs", it calculated that "the average net return to investment in a private school education was 7 per cent for boarders and 13 per cent for day students".

* Above the fact that private school pupils were spending their school lives enjoying facilities normally far better than those available in state schools, these pupils benefited through improved pay in later life, and the financial return is broadly comparable (and probably higher) than returns on other capital."

* The bad news is the study was done 30 years ago and covered the 1970s when real private school fees were lower.

* It found public, yes public, schools produced better maths students than private ones.

* What gives the study cachet is that by only looking at the results for maths, it got around the problems of literacy being influenced by the home environment, other students, culture and even whether the school is in the city or the country.

* let's try a 2007 study. The Center of Education Policy (CEP) in the US reported in Time magazine: "Contrary to popular belief, we can find no evidence that private schools actually increase student performance.
Then it added "instead, it appears that private schools simply have higher percentages of students who would perform well in any environment based on their previous performance and background". Great. When private schools do better, it has nothing to do with them. But here's something to hang your hat on. "It appears private schools do more to develop students' critical-thinking abilities," the CEP says.

* Parents I know choose a school for lots of different reasons, ranging from how much they value religious instruction to the size of classes and even future business contacts. What they don't like to say too loudly is they don't want their kids mixing with the riff raff, preferring the educational equivalent of a gated community.
Don't be embarrassed, economists are on your side. In a submission to the Gonski inquiry into education funding, Deloitte Access Economics says the socio-economic background of the students is one of the most important influences on what it calls, yikes, "educational outcomes".
A high socio-economic background lifts all pupils, while a lower one drags everybody closer to the lowest common denominator.

可以确认的是fee的增长速度远高于inflation,
不能确认的是:毕业后找到好工作的比例,学习成绩好坏,是否全面发展,社会圈子

公校,私校永远是个没有结论的命题, 适合别人的不一定适合你,不适合别人的未必不适合你。只有选择了,才知道合不合适。

评论
没有结论的话题。

评论
这个投资回报是怎么计算出来的?
澳洲中文论坛热点
悉尼部份城铁将封闭一年,华人区受影响!只能乘巴士(组图)
据《逐日电讯报》报导,从明年年中开始,因为从Bankstown和Sydenham的城铁将因Metro South West革新名目而
联邦政客们具有多少房产?
据本月早些时分报导,绿党副首领、参议员Mehreen Faruqi已获准在Port Macquarie联系其房产并建造三栋投资联

小学教育

小学教育

家有爱笑娃的烦恼,求支招

澳大利亚孩子平时非常爱笑乐观simple,总爱帮助别人(help others是老师说的),今年刚刚kindergarten,班级里面有1个女孩总爱打小报告(亚裔不是华人),天天盯着别的同学,做错什么都报告老师 ...

小学教育

小学5 年纪辅导书

澳大利亚请教大家一个问题,小学都用什么辅导书呢? 我家孩子现在5年纪,但是刚过来澳洲,好多东西要补。 报了SCHOLARLY,但是觉得差距不是一般的大啊。 也报了课下辅导班,跟着别的小朋友 ...

小学教育

旧自行车

澳大利亚孩子的同学有个旧自行车,这同学买了个大点的二手车,于是以前的淘汰下来。同学家长说可以给我家孩子用,我问了家长给多少钱,家长说不用。想请教大家我是给钱(给多少?), ...

小学教育

Reject the payroll tax on independent schools

澳大利亚发个投票抵制安德鲁斯关于取消私校payroll tax豁免的法案 https://www.parliament.vic.gov.au/view-sign-e-petitions/details/12/501#msdynttrid=pSajdYtDc32_JGY39nWHSTJ8eqCPVO-j3VQNg5gdlXY 评论 私校都给家长们发信了吧 ...

小学教育

St Ivy North Public School有小伙伴吗

澳大利亚给孩子考虑新学校了。现在在教会学校,我儿子四岁多,说话晚,儿科医生给开了轻度自闭症的诊断,现在的学校新开了特殊教育班,这几天一直劝说我们把儿子转去那边,我们去看了 ...

小学教育

请推荐一所selective补习学校

澳大利亚坐标悉尼西区。明年要考selective了,现在在Selina ho那里补习,感觉效果一般。preuni也去过,作业太多而且净是超前知识,效果也不好。麻烦板上家长推荐一家补习社,谢谢啦。 评论 现在 ...

小学教育

小朋友上语言学校求建议

澳大利亚小朋友今年刚开始一年级,之前一点英语基础都没有。 现在上了3个半月了,感觉进展缓慢,上课什么都听不懂,就是发呆。 现在的小学也没有ESL课程。大概每天早上会有个老师教我们 ...

小学教育

Victorian High-Ability Program有人了解吗?

澳大利亚收到学校邮件,儿子被推荐进这个VHAP。应该是好事。 不过我看了半天这个东西的网站也不太知道它具体有啥用? 貌似就是个短期学习班? 有人了解吗? 多谢。 评论 就一个星期一次网 ...

小学教育

求适合小学生的线上中文学习网站

澳大利亚求适合小学生的线上中文学习网站,有经验的家长请分享。 评论 可以试下LingoAce 评论 感谢分享 评论 我家小朋友们上的线上课挺不错的,老师很有耐心。 最大的好处是家长不需要买大 ...

小学教育

参加Pre_uni奖学金考试

澳大利亚小白一枚,没有去正规补习班,去参加pre_uni scholarship考试,只考了个49%。 是不是OC, selective不用想了? 没有一定要去OC Selective的意思,就是想知道一下水平。孩子平时比较放养,但听说 ...